Monday, July 26, 2010

Leaked Pentagon Files Prove Afghan War is a Massive Waste of Taxpayer Money

The recent unauthorized release of confidential military information regarding the war in Afghanistan is being denounced by the White House, even as it shows that the war is not going well at all, the US military has unfortunately engaged in scandalous actions and the objectives of the war are not remotely being met.
"A whistleblower leaked tens of thousands of secret military files on the Afghan war Monday, documenting the deaths of innocent civilians and how Pakistan's spy agency secretly supports the Taliban.

The leaks prompted a furious reaction from the White House, saying they put the lives of soldiers at risk, but the man behind the revelations said the controversy vindicated the decision to break cover.

In all, some 92,000 documents dating back to 2004 were released by the whistleblowers' website Wikileaks to the New York Times, Britain's Guardian newspaper and Germany's Der Spiegel news weekly.

They carry allegations that Iran is providing money and arms to Taliban insurgents, and details how widespread corruption is hampering a war now in its ninth year.

The New York Times said the archive illustrated "in mosaic detail why, after the United States has spent almost 300 billion dollars on the war, the Taliban are stronger than at any time since 2001" while the Guardian said the files painted "a devastating portrait of the failing war."

The White House response is almost Orwellian, as it objects to the release of this information on the grounds that it will "put soldier's lives at risk".

Actually, what is putting American soldier's lives at risk is the decision by that same White House to continue to wage this pointless, budget-draining war in the first place.

It's always curious when an objection is lodged related to the release of otherwise private information and that objection does not allege that the leaked information is false, misleading or otherwise untrue. Here, there's no apparent reason that the American public, which, you know, is actually paying for this war, has been denied access to this now-leaked information. The person that leaked this information deserves our praise for his courage and willingness to show that the Emporer has no clothes!

It will be interesting to see how the mainstream media plays this release. In my humble view, the release of this information is as potentially troubling to the Obama Administration as the release of the so-called Pentagon Papers was to the Nixon Administration during the Vietnam War.

Of course, unlike President Nixon, President Obama has many supporters in the mainstream media, so they may choose to protect him by whitewashing this story. Time will tell.

There is no disputing, however, the fact the leak of this information demonstrates once again that the American military is over-taxed in its overseas combat entanglements and stirs up more trouble in its overseas antics than it is able to fix by being overseas in the first place.

Time to bring the boys home for good and reduce our military spending dramatically.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

Michael Steele Is Right

Michael Steele, current and soon-to-be-former Chairman of the Republican National Committee, recently stated his position that the Afghanistan war should now be considered President Obama's fight and should be judged accordingly.
"Keep in mind again, federal candidates, this was a war of Obama's choosing. This is not something the United States had actively prosecuted or wanted to engage in," Steele said. "If he's such a student of history, has he not understood that you know that's the one thing you don't do, is engage in a land war in Afghanistan? All right, because everyone who has tried, over a thousand years of history, has failed. And there are reasons for that."
Now technically Steele may have been remiss in not pointing out that the Afghanistan war was started under President Bush.

However, the point that I believe Michael Steele is making is that each President has the option at the outset of their administration to decide whether they support and wish to continue the decisions of prior Administrations or not.

President Obama did not just support the Afghanistan war, he advocated prosecuting it much more aggressively than President Bush had been.

As a result, President Obama now "owns" the war that we continue to unnecessarily squander massive amounts of taxpayer money on.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

McChrystal, Petraeus...Who Cares?

As Senate starts the confirmation hearings for General David Petraeus as a replacement for the intemperate General Stanley McChrystal, his overall mission in Afghanistan comes into focus.

"In some ways, the hearing will echo much of what Petraeus told the Senate and House armed-services committees recently, as nervous lawmakers sought his calm demeanor to soothe their own heebie-jeebies over a war that increasingly seems bogged down. Senator Carl Levin, the Michigan Democrat who chairs the Senate panel, said Monday that it is likely to zero in on two key questions: How firm is President Obama's July 2011 date to begin withdrawing U.S. troops from Afghanistan, and why isn't the Afghan military doing more to defeat the Taliban?"

Instead of asking whether we can possibly start to withdraw troops at some point next year (and by "withdraw", we're probably talking the same, slow process that have seen American troops "withdraw" from Korea following the Korean War over half a century ago) Americans should be asking why our military is still in Afghanistan right now at all. Now the longest-running war in US history, the fight in Afghanistan has rolled on for years without much visible progress.

Afghanistan is still economically dependent on drug sales, Taliban warlords still control a good part of the country and people there are still openly hostile to Western society.

If we're concerned that upon leaving the Taliban will return to complete power and provide Al Qaeda with a safe haven to conduct their nefarious operations, well they're already currently able to operate with impunity from the badlands of Pakistan.

Besides, the true key to defeating Al Qaeda has never been about meeting them on an open battle field and obliterating them, but rather scaling back our overly-aggressive foreign policy we have adopted over the past 70 years in which we interfere in foreign elections and politics, and occupy countries on a whim.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Undiscovered Mineral Wealth in Afghanistan?

Those noted geologists that work for the US military recently announced their "discovery" of trillions of dollars worth of minerals in Afghanistan.
"The United States has discovered nearly $1 trillion in untapped mineral deposits in Afghanistan, far beyond any previously known reserves and enough to fundamentally alter the Afghan economy and perhaps the Afghan war itself, according to senior American government officials.

The previously unknown deposits — including huge veins of iron, copper, cobalt, gold and critical industrial metals like lithium — are so big and include so many minerals that are essential to modern industry that Afghanistan could eventually be transformed into one of the most important mining centers in the world, the United States officials believe."
There should be no dispute that Afghanistan likely has huge veins of minerals. However, having minerals and actually be able to mine those same minerals and bring them to market (over exceedingly tough terrain that is nowhere near a port for shipment to a smelter) in an economic manner are two different things.

In short, it could be completely true that Afghanistan does in fact possess a trillion dollars worth of metals. But if it costs a trillion dollars (or more) to pull those same metals out of the ground and sell them, then they will remain in the ground for ever more.

It's telling that the US released no geological studies or feasibility reports when announcing their "discovery". A similar move by a micro-cap company listed on an exchange in the US would likely draw an immediate rebuke from the SEC.

The announcement from the US government is so hokey that one can't help but wonder what the ulterior motive is for the release of this information.

Perhaps it's this: if Afghanistan can be shown to have a viable post-war economic future, then maybe the American people can in effect be asked to continue to put up with it and continue to pay for it out of their tax dollars for just a little while longer until the military can sort things out just enough for us to declare victory and exit.

Labels:

FREE hit counter and Internet traffic statistics from freestats.com